In almost every discussion regarding the controversial Escondido Country Club property and Proposition H, I am asked about two legal issues:
I am no lawyer, and understanding property rights law is difficult even for the most qualified legal eagles. But I have uncovered two similar cases that have seen interesting, and maybe even surprising, rulings against property owners who want to convert golf course properties to residential housing tracts.
Here is a brief summary I have compiled from some legal websites.
Heatherwood Holdings, LLC vs. Homeowners
A federal court of appeals held that a golf course was encumbered by an implied restrictive covenant, preventing the foreclosing lender from selling the golf course for residential development.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit found that the original marketing of a subdivision where the golf course was located played a significant role in establishing an implied restrictive covenant.
Although the court found that there were no recorded covenants restricting the property's use to a golf course, it held that the property was limited to golf course use by an implied restrictive covenant, evidenced in large part by the testimony of homeowners who stated that the presence of the golf course was integral to their decisions to purchase in the subdivision.
Liberty Building Corporation vs. Skyline Woods Homeowners
In 2004, Skyline Woods Country Club LLC filed a voluntary petition for relief under chapter 11 bankruptcy. The court entered a sale order authorizing the sale of substantially all of the debtor’s assets, including a golf course, to an affiliate of Liberty Building Corp. The sale order provided that the sale was “free and clear of claims, liens and encumbrances.”
Months later, Liberty announced that it would not reopen the golf course, but rather would redevelop the property for other purposes (a housing tract).
Shortly thereafter, homeowners in the residential development located around the golf course brought suit against Liberty in Nebraska state court seeking to prohibit Liberty from using the property as anything other than a golf course.
The homeowners contended that:
On March 28, 2007, the state court granted the homeowners’ summary judgment motion, finding that the 'implied restrictive covenants'
B) Can a City legally down-zone a property after it is sold to someone who reasonably believes it is zoned for residential construction?
There are certain limitations on downzoning. The first limitation is the constitutional prohibition against taking private property without just compensation, stated in the Fifth Amendment of the Constitution. This has been interpreted as meaning that property cannot be rezoned to a category that leaves it with 'no reasonable economic use.'
For instance, property used as a golf course may be rezoned from residential (which usually permits golf course and other uses) to a category that allows the property to be used only as a golf course. This prevents redevelopment and presumably insures that the property will continue to be used as a golf course.
Contrary to the popular opinion, zoning does not go too far simply because it causes a loss. That act alone does not constitute a 'taking.'
In the case of the Escondido City Council's adaptation of the Homeowners Property Rights Initiative that effectively rezones the golf course as 'park/open space use only,' the new zoning would still allow the property to be used as a golf course.
Therefore, the new owner cannot claim the land has no reasonable use. He bought a golf course and can, reasonably, still use it as a golf course if he chooses.
What Happened to Our Community?
The story of how a quiet corner of paradise has devolved into
To review the timelines of this ongoing saga, just <click> on any Month below....
You might also like:
What happened on November 9th, 2016? Can anyone tell us how Donald Trump became leader of the free world?
Will Progressives ever own up to how they have divided the country? They whine and complain, but the truth is their policies always result in unintended consequences.
I explore how Trump's Reckoning with the Cult of Progressivism is the only medicine that can restore the American Spirit of Exceptionalism, and how the world needs Americanism to thrive.
Click here to buy it now!